Home EFF, Apache Software Foundation, and Microsoft Urge Supreme Court to Revise Patent Law

EFF, Apache Software Foundation, and Microsoft Urge Supreme Court to Revise Patent Law

The Electronic Frontier Foundation, the Apache Software Foundation, and the Computer & Communications Industry Association filed an amicus brief in support of Microsoft today, asking the U.S. Supreme Court for a ruling that would have a major impact on patent litigation.

The EFF brief, filed alongside 10 others – including ones from Facebook, Intel, and Apple – stems from the $290 million patent infringement judgement against Microsoft. In 2009, a district court found Microsoft guilty of infringing on the patents of the Canadian software company i4i. i4i holds a patent for building a method of processing custom XML, a method i4i claimed – and the courts agreed – that Microsoft violated with its 2003 and subsequent versions of Word.

While Microsoft has failed to win its case so far via the appeal system, it filed a certiorari petition – a request for judicial review – with the Supreme Court in August asking the high court to review the standards for determining a patent’s validity. This revision would benefit defendants in infringement cases.

Different Standards for Patent Plaintiffs and Defendants

Currently, in order to invalidate a patent, “clear and convincing” evidence is required. Microsoft argues in its petition that there is no need to have a standard that high. Rather, defendants should be able to challenge patents with the less onerous “preponderance of the evidence” standard. In other words, writes EFF, “‘Clear and convincing’ means that the facts are ‘highly probable,’ which is a much more difficult standard to meet when trying to invalidate a patent than just a preponderance.”

That’s the same standard that is required for a patent-holding plaintiff to prove that a defendant has infringed on a patent, and Microsoft argues that by making both parties adhere to the lower standard, it levels the litigation playing field.

The Impact of Patents – and Trolls – on the Tech World

Law.com cites John Thorne, deputy general counsel at Verizon, who submitted a brief alongside Google, as saying that “For the whole high-tech community, this issue of bad patents being asserted by trolls is a huge issue. More patents are issuing, products are getting more complicated, and lawsuits are increasing.”

EFF argues in its brief that the requirement that an accused infringer prove patent invalidity by “clear and convincing” evidence unfairly burdens patent defendants, particularly those in the free and open-source software community.

The Supreme Court rarely hears these sorts of petitions, and earlier this summer “punted” when its decision in the Bilski case failed to address some of the core problems surrounding software patents, something that as the companies and organizations supporting Microsoft today contend, dampens innovation.

Photo credits: Flickr user Brian Turner

About ReadWrite’s Editorial Process

The ReadWrite Editorial policy involves closely monitoring the tech industry for major developments, new product launches, AI breakthroughs, video game releases and other newsworthy events. Editors assign relevant stories to staff writers or freelance contributors with expertise in each particular topic area. Before publication, articles go through a rigorous round of editing for accuracy, clarity, and to ensure adherence to ReadWrite's style guidelines.

Get the biggest tech headlines of the day delivered to your inbox

    By signing up, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

    Tech News

    Explore the latest in tech with our Tech News. We cut through the noise for concise, relevant updates, keeping you informed about the rapidly evolving tech landscape with curated content that separates signal from noise.

    In-Depth Tech Stories

    Explore tech impact in In-Depth Stories. Narrative data journalism offers comprehensive analyses, revealing stories behind data. Understand industry trends for a deeper perspective on tech's intricate relationships with society.

    Expert Reviews

    Empower decisions with Expert Reviews, merging industry expertise and insightful analysis. Delve into tech intricacies, get the best deals, and stay ahead with our trustworthy guide to navigating the ever-changing tech market.