According to latest report from China Internet Network Information
Center (CNNIC), by end of 2007, there are over 200 million Internet users
(including 163 million broadband users) in China. 2008 is shaping up to be a very busy year
for the Chinese Internet, and the Chinese market seems to be pulsing with social networking activity. But for Chinese Internet users, social networking has taken on a very different form than it has in Western countries. In China, the most popular form of networking may just be the traditional Internet forum system, or BBS.
That’s not to say traditional social networking is dead — far from it. You can find QZone which is owned by Tencent
with the support of QQ’s over 220
millions active users. Then there is 51.com which proclaims 160,000 new users daily; Linkist
Wealink are two popular professional networks
based in Shanghai; Tianji.com is
another professional network based in Beijing and it has partnered with Viadeo, one of the world’s largest online
business communities to create a premier business platform for online networking
between China and Europe; Xiaonei, Zhanzuo and many others are sharing the campus
social networking market.
With its massive user base, the Chinese market is naturally one of the most attractive places for Western networks to attemp to set up shop. MySpace has set up an office in
Beijing; Facebook might acquire a Chinese
SNS, Fenbei.com, and surely will have local
presence in 2008; Friendster
has done very well in the South East Asian market and expects similar success in China. Xing, a professional network from
Europe, set up a Chinese office back in 2005; Last.fm
is trying to be more localized in China to compete with 9Sky, Yobo, and 8box.
Surprisingly, though, one of the most popular methods for Chinese netizens to communicate exists far from the web 2.0 scene: traditional Bulletin Board Systems (BBS). BBS actually plays a very
significant role in Chinese Internet life. In China, registered BBS users have
reached 3 billion (one netizen might register at multiple BBS sites);
80% of Chinese sites are running their own BBS and the total number of daily page views across bulletin board systems has reached over 1.6 billion, with 10 million posts published every day. The BBS is an undiscovered and untalked about Chinese Internet phenomenon. To understand more about why BBS is so hot in China and how it will
co-exist with modern social networks, we interviewed Kevin Day the CEO
and founder of Comsenz Inc., owner of Discuz!, the first ever social platform – a
BBS system – for the Chinese Internet. More than 400,000 BBS sites are built on the Discuz!
system in China, or in other words, Discuz! controls over 70% of the Chinese BBS market.
The Phenomenon of Chinese BBS
According to a report produced by iResearch Consulting Group in 2007, around 36.3% of users in China spend 1-3 hours per day on BBS sites, about
44.7% of users spend 3-8 hours, and even 15.1% of users are on BBS sites for more than 8
hours each day. Over 60% of users will log in to at least 3 BBS sites more than 3 times each week.
According to the report, the primary reasons for using BBS sites is
finding solutions to problems, general discussion, finding information, and sharing life experiences. 98% of users have
contributed to a BBS by publishing articles, replying to posts, participating
in polls, etc. Users tend to trust BBS sites because they think the information found on them is first-hand, updated frequently, and presented in a comfortable, community environment.
Chinese BBS life has apparently extended offline, as well. The report also
says 64.5% of users have attended some offline events organized by BBS
administrators or users. More than 80% of users are using BBS sites to search for information about products they plan to buy, and 61.7% of users are keen to ask other BBS users for opinions before making a purchase. Astonishingly, BBS sites are even acting as ecommerce hubs themselves, with 47.3% of users having bought products directly from a BBS.
The screenshot below shows a BBS set up by the fans of Jinglei Xu, a very
famous Chinese celebrity and blogger. This site has over 65,420 registered
users, and you can find thousands of online communities like this one built on
traditional BBS software.
The History of Discuz!
If you ever log onto a Chinese BBS site, most likely it is built on the
Discuz! system. Discuz! was originally developed by Kevin Day when he was at his first
year in university. In 2002, the first version of Discuz! was sold to a Hong Kong
based company, and in 2003, Day decided to discontinue his studies and
founded Comsenz Inc. in 2004 in Beijing.
In 2005, Comsenz Inc. partnered with Zend and established the Zend China support center. Later in 2005, Day announced that Discuz! was going open source, which
has been described by local media as an earthquake for the Chinese software industry.
Comsenz Inc. got its first round of funding for around $10 million from Sequoia Captial,
Morningside, and Google in 2006.
Now Comsenz Inc. has grown to a household name
with 200+ staff and a complete product line that includes Discuz! (bulletin
board), X-Space (social Network
platform), SupeSite (content management
system), ECShop (open source B2C and C2C
system) and SupeV (online videosharing
system). It is also running a few Internet services, including a free forum
hosting service 5d6d, a free B2B shop hosting
service Maifou, and a community advertising
network Insenz. Day is just 26 years
old, but he has been publicly recognized as the one of the most successful entrepreneurs born in 1980s.
The BBS and Social Networks
With 70% of Chinese BBS sites built on Discuz!, Day is obviously a key figure behind the phenomenon. So we asked him why he thought BBS systems have become so popular in China. “The first Chinese BBS was probably set up back in
1997. Like Email, BBS is one of the first Internet services recognized by
Chinese netizens,” he told us. “Chinese like the communities, they are normally a bit quiet in
real life but in Internet they love to express their opinion and to follow up
some discussion of hot topics. BBS provides a perfect and easy-to-setup show
stage for everyone. BBS has evolved as a media platform, it is not the main
stream media yet and might never be in China, but the latest and hottest news
are always from various forums, spread and discussed by millions of users.
“Take a look at how fast the blog grows in China, you will
understand my point here. The BBS users are more mature, they are mainly at the
age of 20 to 40, well-educated and with various professional background, and
their contribution to all sorts of forums make BBS a valuable information
With social networking on the rise in the Western world and also in China, we asked Day if he thought social networking sites would eventually replace the BBS in Chinese culture.
“BBS will not be replaced by SNS and they will not be the competitors
to each other either,” he answered. “BBS is a must-to-have application in SNS, at least in
China. The features of BBS can help the social network users to exchange their
ideas efficiently. On the other hand, SNS is a people-centric networking
platform but BBS is a topic-centric platform. SNS is to map the social
relationship in real life into the cyber space, which in my opinion is one of
the reasons people love Facebook; But BBS is there for users to follow the
hottest topics and expand your social experience virtually. In BBS, people go
there because they are interested in the topics, and whom they communicate with
does not really matter.”
The Monetization of BBS
The global social networking market is still struggling to seek the best methods for
monetization, but it seems that BBS sites have already found a way to drive revenue. Day introduced us to his Insenz product, a
BBS-based marketing service that was launched about six months ago. At its core, Insenz is basically a Chinese version of Google’s Adsense/AdWord services focused on BBS sites. If you are
running a BBS focusing on the mobile phones market, for example, you can join the Insenz
advertisement program and get mobile phone related ads or articles posted
on your BBS.
Insenz’s customer are from all sorts of industries,
car manufacturers, telecommunications, IT companies, etc. Insenz will monitor user feeback (e.g. how many replies to the article, how many times the post has been viewed, etc.) during the campaign and issue a report to marketers that includes valuable first-hand marketing information. The BBS sites that participate in the marketing campaigns get a cut of the revenue.
Of course Insenz takes the advantage of Day’s Discuz! kingdom. But actually,
in China, Insenz is not the only company offering this service. Daqi.com, which started as a portal service, is now also taking advantage of the BBS phenomenon for marketing purposes.
Instead of distributing ads across forums, they invented a technology to
help gather and analyze discussions about the products of their customers.
Daqi closed its second round fund from WI Harper in 2007.
A universal BBS search engine will definitely be more valuable than blog
search in China, though Day said that he would not bother to do this
simply because he thinks the search engine giants Google or Baidu have better
technology to implement it. It seems that Google China has noticed the popularity of BBS sites in the Chinese Intneret market, and have recently taken a stake in Tianya.cn, a very popular BBS-based social network
with 6+ million registered users and 200,000 online users daily. So should MySpace, Facebook, and other traditional Western social networks endeavor to enhance their BBS features if they want to play in China?
What do you think? Leave your thoughts in the comments below.